It began when I called someone a dipshit on Thanksgiving. (To be fair, the object of my displeasure–me– earned the sobriquet.) What a word, I mused: it must be a compound of the verb dip and shit, as if someone incompetent or stupid was so repugnant that they might as well be “dipped in shit.”
Alas for etymological fallacy: dipshit is not a compound created from the verb dip and the noun shit. It is, instead, a compound of the earlier noun dip, meaning “a stupid or incompetent person,” and the noun shit.
So who gives a fuck? I give said fuck. I had always assumed that dip was the bowdlerization of dipshit. Instead, it turns out that dipshit is an expansion and intensification of the earlier, tamer dip. It is expurgation turned ass over teakettle. Dip not strong enough for you? Just add –shit and stir.
The intensifying –shit isn’t a one-off found in dipshit; it also appears in apeshit (“wild, crazy”), chickenshit (“cowardly”), and bullshit (“foolish, empty talk”).
Bullshit is the earliest of our shitty words, first showing up in written English prose in 1914. Though the etymological bull in bullshit is likely the animal, there’s no doubt that bullshit was heavily influenced by another bull: a 17th century noun that referred first to a bad joke, then to a bad blunder, then to empty talk, and finally to errant nonsense. The “empty talk” sense of bull was in solid verbal use by the time bullshit showed up in print; at the very least, the intensified bullshit grew up with bull. But etymologists agree: bull is definitely not a shortening of bullshit.
Chickenshit has a forked line of derivation. The noun chicken has been used of a coward since Shakespeare, and was used attributively for quite a while. The adjective chickenshit made its written debut in 1945 and the noun in 1947. The glories of chickenshit owe everything to the complexity of chicken: chicken didn’t just refer to a coward, but also to a timid or meek person, someone who was afraid to try something new or do something out of line. This excerpt from a 1945 issue of American Speech explains, “A person is ‘chicken’ when he abides too closely by army rules and regulations, or when he misuses or abuses authority, especially in minor or petty matters.” Accordingly, the earliest meanings of both the adjective and noun chickenshit had to do with minuteness, pettiness, and insignificance. The “coward” sense of both chickenshits developed almost simultaneously, and while both showed up in written prose immediately after World War II, there’s no doubt that they were in use well before. The –shit here is not merely an intensifier, but also a humiliator. You are not just a filthy, brainless bird, obsessed with birdseed and bugs, and ready to cluck off at the slightest provocation, you are worse than that: you are that idiot bird’s shit.
Apeshit is our latest addition, first used in written English prose in 1951. It is mostly commonly used with go and it began, appropriately, as military slang. (God bless those soldiers, they know how to fucking swear.) Go apeshit came into being roughly the same time that the milder go ape did, but both phrases have developed slightly different connotations over the years: go ape tends to imply a happy, usually harmless frenzy, whereas go apeshit almost always refers to violent or other ill-mannered explosions. Compare:
The day after the brawl Edmundo went ape. To celebrate the first birthday of his son, Junior, he hired an entire circus for the day. (Sports Illustrated, 18 Oct. 1999)
“It’s Clete Purcel. He went apeshit in Calucci’s and ran one guy all the way through the glass window. The guy’s still lying in the flower bed.” (James Lee Burke, Dixie City Jam, 1994)
There are more words hauling the intensifying –shit behind them; Green’s Dictionary of Slang includes delights like bugshit, diddly-shit, and jack shit, as in “you don’t know ~.” (My co-contributor Mark Peters has mentioned a few other affixal –shits in his post on frogshit.) It is a comfort to know that there are wordsmiths out there interested not so much in the neutering of shitty compounds, but in the abundant creation of them. There’s plenty of –shit to go around.
When I was growing up, “dipshit” was (one of) my father’s go-to swears. Years later, when I looked up and learned that a “dip” element refers to a “stupid or incompetent person,” I had two realizations. One, way to add insult to injury, Dad. Two, he typically reserved it for when my brothers or I committed some sort of stupid mistake: For example, “Wait, you noticed the tire pressure was low two weeks ago and you didn’t do anything about it? You dipshit.” (Geez, I must of been making a lot of little mistakes! It is a son’s duty, really.) I think back to it fondly now, of course, but also admire its effective specific and appropriate usage.
LikeLiked by 1 person
What about “batshit”? Like “batshit crazy”? I’ve wondered about that one.
“Batshit” is a good one. It first showed up in print in 1950 (or thereabouts) to refer to something worthless. Under the influence of “apeshit,” it gained the “crazy” sense around 1971.
But this isn’t necessarily a case of the intensifying “-shit”: there’s no sense of “bat” that means “something worthless.” This looks like comparison to me: something that is worthless or contemptible is worth less than bat shit. (Though I hear bat shit is a pretty decent plant fertilizer, so what do neologists know?)
LikeLiked by 1 person
There’s no sense of “batty” that means “something worthless,” but batty certainly means crazy by itself. Why then is not “batshit crazy” an intensifier of the sort you are describing in this post?
A dip in the road needs a warning sign.
So, is ‘horseshit’ a shitty-come-lately imitation of ‘bullshit’?
It looks like it–horseshit first showed up in English prose in 1923 meaning “nonsense.”
In my own profanilect (thanks, Stan Carey, for this beaut of a word), horseshit and bullshit have slightly different registers and uses. Horseshit has a stronger, more derisive feel to me, whereas bullshit is milder in tone. That’s likely because bullshit has uses that are broader and more jocular: call bullshit on (someone or something), for instance. Where I’m from, if you call something horseshit, there’s no mistaking it for a joke. (Usual disclaimers apply: YMMV, void where prohibited.)
I inherited horseshit from my friend PK, who uses it with pointed aplomb. At first I took to it because it was less common than bullshit, but I also like how it sounds; similarly to shite vs. shit, I think you can do more expressive things with the word.
Another sign of bullshit‘s broader currency is the popular initialism BS, which is handy on Twitter when there’s (tragically) no room for horseshit or any other zoological variety.
LikeLiked by 1 person
You need nonbreaking hyphen as first character in what you are rendering as -shit.
I am no wow, I had thought that “dipshit” was a slur directed against gay men… (non-native English speaker)
Dipshit is a general term of abuse in English (or American English, at least) and not specifically directed at gay men.
Wait, wait, hang on. I just searched this page and found no mention of the word “dipsomaniac”? What am I missing, or what dream etymology have liens implanted with all the other false memories?